
The WebTexan
April 8, 1998
THE HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH GLOBAL SHOWCASE
Documentary Film Festival Brings International,
Domestic Human Rights Issues to Light
Government, Lies, Politics, Abuse,
Death
Rene Penalosa-Galvan
Daily Texan Staff
Documentary films that take a stand on political issues have often
been stigmatized as propagandistic by both filmmakers and audiences.
As a result, many of today's political documentaries are bland, foregoing
analysis and criticism in an ill-conceived attempt to appear objective.
Caught between propaganda and superficiality, documentarians face a daunting
task when dealing with politically-charged subject matter.
For a five-day span, running today through Monday, The Human Rights Watch
Global Showcase will show films that meet this challenge, tackling pressing
issues head-on. The festival, locally sponsored by Amnesty International
to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights, will give viewers a chance to encounter a unique and rarely-seen
type of cinema: films that vividly incarnate key human rights issues currently
affecting societies around the world. "These are issues
that are all hard to deal with," explains Tammy Arnstein, one of
the showcase organizers. "Saying, 'Well, I'm not going to go and
watch these films because they have a political angle,' I think, is the
easy way to dismiss them."
The program's most prominent offering is also the one that hits closest
to home. Waco: The Rules of Engagement is a shattering look at the numerous,
appalling governmental irregularities that surrounded the Branch Davidian
fiasco. Far from advocating sensationalistic conspiracy theories, the
film undertakes a convincingly thorough and intelligent analysis.
Off-screen narration is kept to a minimum as interviews are intercut with
congressional hearings and video testimonials made by the Branch Davidians
during the ordeal, imbuing the documentary with a chilling immediacy.
Its unmitigated disclosure of government negligence was most likely what
denied this superb work the Oscar it was nominated for.
By addressing these U.S. human rights violations, such a documentary dispels
the widespread myth that such issues pertain solely to underdeveloped
or developing countries.
"In general, human rights seem to be very distant, like someone tortured
in Cambodia or in Argentina or in Brazil," says Susana Kaiser, another
festival organizer. "What I think is important about this festival,
if you look at the program, [is that] four films are about this country."
Besides Waco, the remaining U.S. films deal with issues ranging from
domestic violence (It Ain't Love) to immigration legislation in California
(Fear and Learning at Hoover Elementary). For its part, Blacks and Jews
provides some fresh insight into the inescapable issue of racial tension.
The festival also addresses human rights in yet another country that doesn't
normally figure into discussions on the topic -- Japan. Barizogon explores
economic corruption on the island by focusing on the case of an unsafe
nuclear plant and the man who tried to unveil the cover-up.
Blacks and Jews explores relations between the two groups using five riveting
stories of rage, courage and hope. The film plays Sunday at 5 p.m.
In addition to exposing pressing human rights issues in developed countries,
the festival also deals with better-known -- yet equally important --
issues. Such films offer viewers a true understanding of issues that have
received fragmented, superficial coverage in the mainstream media.
Along this vein, Chronicle of a Genocide Foretold sheds much-needed light
on the circumstances leading to ethnic war in Rwanda, suggesting the disturbing
possibility that 500,000 deaths could have been prevented.
The festival also examines the Chechnyan war (The Betrayed); the "disappearance"
of political dissidents in Brazil (15 Children); American encroachment
on national sovereignty in Latin America (Devils Don't Dream!); and human
rights in the Middle East (Stories of Honor and Shame and Jerusalem: An
Occupation Set in Stone).
Finally, Cuba and Russia provide a landscape of fading and faded communist
revolutions in Ricardo, Miriam, and Fidel and Bye, Bye, Babushka, respectively."The
point is to try to connect particular issues," Susana Kaiser, one
of the festival's organizers, explains. "The challenge is
to say, 'OK, this is happening over there in that place, but how about
in our societies?'"As part of the effort to promote local awareness
and understanding of human rights, the screenings (besides being free
to the public) will also include a brief introduction to the issues within
the ensuing film, provided by a specialist on the topic and complemented
by a discussion afterwards. "Every film has a viewpoint," says
Donna Lovong, a representative of Amnesty International, one of the co-sponsors
of the festival. "People can have opinions on the films ... they
might not even agree with the films -- that's the whole point."
Slanted or not, the filmmakers whose documentaries will make up the festival
have certainly left behind the limitations of entertainment and art in
favor of a nobler -- and perhaps more substantial -- task: to meaningfully
and directly affect the plight of their subjects through their work.
Copyright ©1998 The WebTexan |